Click Here For Story
by Michael Arrington on January 2, 2010
Last week two bloggers, Steven Frischling and Chris Elliot, were visited by TSA agents and threatened with jail time if they did not reveal their source of the TSA Travel Directive that they each published shortly after the attempted terrorist attack on Christmas day. Frischling caved immediately and handed over his computer. Elliot did not. Since then the Department of Homeland Security has dropped the subpoenas, but there is a bigger issue here. The protection of sources is a cornerstone of our freedom of speech.
As bloggers, we have a duty of confidentiality to our sources. And that means keeping information confidential even if threatened with the tyranny of government. And even if the legislatures and courts haven’t decided that as bloggers we have real rights protecting us from that tyranny.
I’ll never be surprised by a tyrannical government. In a sense, it’s their job. It’s our job as bloggers to stand up to that tyranny, even if our liberty has been threatened. Journalists have gone to jail rather than disclose their sources. If bloggers want the same level of respect, and protection from government by the courts, they need to stand up for what’s right.
And Frischling, when faced with the decision to do what’s right and go to jail, flailed badly. He willingly handed his laptop over to the government.
Easy To Say, Hard To Do
You could argue that it’s easy for me to make statements like this, since we blog about technology. The Department of Homeland Security doesn’t knock on my door very often demanding to know my source for the latest Google acquisition rumor. But if they did, I’d like to think I’d tell them to go to hell. Even if that meant they dragged me out of my house and put me in jail.
We have received a number of threats of lawsuits unless we revealed our sources around various sensitive stories. In each case we’ve either ignored the threats or told them to pound sand. In each case the other side backed down.
We’ve also had other situations where we’ve had to consider revealing sources. In March 2008 we wrote about acquisition negotiations between Digg and Google. The companie’s CEO Jay Adelson effectively called us liars, and we were sorely tempted to reveal our original source. But to do so would mean that people would know that under certain circumstances they couldn’t trust us. We want that trust to be unconditional, and so we took our lumps and never revealed the source. Later we had our vindication anyway.
We were challenged yet again in 2009 with the Last.fm/RIAA story where we believe at least one source, including an executive at Last.fm, lied to us. We haven’t, and never will, publish that information. Even though there’s an email string that would make excellent reading.
And there is a whole book I could write around the Twitter document fiasco from 2009. That book will never be written either.
I think I can understand how frightened Frischling must have been when the TSA agents showed up at his house. Even though he has has worked for Life, Time, Newsweek, New York Times, and was embedded with troops in Iraq, he “didn’t know what to do.” He caved, and he gave the agents his computer. From Wired:
“They were indicating there would be significant ramifications if I didn’t cooperate,” said Frischling, who was home alone with his three children when the agents arrived. “It’s not hard to intimidate someone when they’re holding a 3-year-old [child] in their hands. My wife works at night. I go to jail, and my kids are here with nobody.”
His argument is that he received the email from an anonymous source via Gmail, so he wasn’t really handing over confidential information. But the TSA, seeing the email, can then easily get Google to hand over information around that Gmail account, and can likely track down the source. Any anyway, it doesn’t matter. At the end of the day, he lacked the courage to stand up for what’s right.
Anyone working with Frischling now knows that he’ll respect your confidentiality, just so long as it’s not inconvenient to his liberty. And that’s not respect at all. He let all bloggers down the other day when he willingly handed over his computer to the government. It was his duty to stand up to those agents, and even spend time in jail. Perhaps if he fought the whole situation in court it would lead to stronger laws protecting all bloggers. But Frischling didn’t do that, and the tyranny of our government went unchecked once more.
If I’m ever in the same situation as Steven Frischling I hope I have the courage to do what’s right. Not just what’s right for me right then.
Archives
-
▼
2010
(74)
-
▼
January
(62)
- Michele Bachmann- Hypocrite? You Decide.
- Proof of American Stupidity? You Decide
- Why Atheists Don't Turn to Religion When Faced wit...
- SPENDING FREEZE MUST INCLUDE DEFENSE
- Obama Fails to Rally Progressive Base in 'Tepid' A...
- CIA Man Retracts Claim on Waterboarding
- The Sorry State of the Union
- A Jerk By Any Other Name is Still A Jerk: Andre B...
- Democracy in America Is a Useful Fiction
- Medical marijuana patients face transplant hurdles
- Audited By The IRS for Being Poor
- South Carolina Lt. Gov. Andre Bauer Compares Need...
- Prop 8 Trial Reenactment Trailer
- IS THE UNITED STATES THE NEW BANANA REPUBLIC ? YOU...
- SCOTUS eviscerates campaign finance regulations: W...
- The U.S. boasts a long and shameful history of sil...
- To save democracy, we must destroy it ~ by Andrew ...
- Whose Rights?
- Obama Puts Social Security on the Chopping Block
- Supporting Democrats....
- U.S. Military Weapons Inscribed With Secret 'Jesus...
- GIVING WITHOUT A 'COMMANDMENT' ~ KUDOS TO THE ATHE...
- "SPIRITUAL CONSPIRACY"
- Seems As Though H&M's 'Brand Integrity' Has Never ...
- Rep. Virginia Foxx (R)
- System Failure
- Big Insurance Funds Chamber of Commerce to Kill He...
- Meet Harold Ford, JR. ~ Ann Coulter's Favorite Dem...
- Health Insurers Funded Chamber Attack Ads
- George W. Obama
- How Much Do You REALLY Know About The Federal Rese...
- Fair Elections: The Basics
- Independent News Sources - Projectcensored.org
- Here comes the screw job
- The Implosion of the American Political Consciousness
- US CONGRE$$ Sells Out to Wall $treet
- The Media Can Legally Lie
- Why Democrats Are Trying to Commit Electoral Suicide
- Dan Rather on media consolidation and "junk news"
- Why Is the Whistleblower Who Exposed the Massive U...
- The DEA and The War on Doctors / Pain Crisis
- Insurance Company Greed
- End Forced Arbitration
- How Washington is Screwing Up Health Care Reform –...
- Boyle's law applied to "Hell"
- What could've been had He not sold us out
- WellPoint sued an ENTIRE STATE to increase profits
- Senator Sanders Unfiltered: US Congress Bought & P...
- AlterNet~ 14 Most Heinous Climate Villains
- Are Feds Trying to Get Rid of IRS Agent-Turned-Tax...
- "..I don't know that atheists should be considered...
- Teach Big Banks A Lesson, Move Your Money
- 1797 TREATY WITH TRIPOLI AND KEEPING RELIGION OUT ...
- What to Do if You are Stopped By The Police.
- The Unconstitutional War On Civil Liberties
- The Tyranny Of Government And Our Duty Of Confiden...
- The Eleven Truths of Tyranny
- SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE ?
- C Street House, Religion, Scandal And Hypocrisy
- Fourteen Defining Characteristics Of Fascism
- The Corporation
- Cheney has invested 85 million dollars in a mutual...
-
▼
January
(62)
The Tyranny Of Government And Our Duty Of Confidentiality As Bloggers
Wednesday, January 6, 2010Posted by For The People By the People: You Decide. at 12:24 PM
Labels: confidentiality, government tyranny
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 comments:
Post a Comment